Jeni’s announces the return of its wildly popular, extraordinarily divisive (but also very delicious) Everything Bagel ice cream
It’s perhaps a once-in-a-blue-moon occurrence that any dish, let alone an ice cream, creates such a stir. Even rarer still is a flavor that shocks-and-awes and delivers on its promise to be delicious. Because you can argue the merits of whether or not this flavor should exist—actually, Jeni’s is hoping that you do! But no one can—or did—dispute that the ice cream tastes exactly like an everything bagel with cream cheese. And that it’s delicious (or, worst case, not at all an unpleasant experience).